Breaking NewsPolitics

The Judgment That Changed Itself: Gachagua’s Explosive New Appeal Claims Court Altered Its Own Ruling

Something unusual is happening in Kenya’s highest political legal battle.

Former Deputy President Rigathi Gachagua has just filed a massive 121-volume appeal at the Court of Appeal. But this is not the usual “we disagree with the judges” filing.

At the heart of his challenge is a startling claim: the High Court judgment that upheld his impeachment is not the same judgment that was read out loud in open court.

According to Gachagua’s lawyers, four critical paragraphs that were delivered orally by Justices Eric Ogola, Anthony Mrima and Fridah Mugambi on 8 June 2026 somehow disappeared from the final written version. Those missing sections, he argues, touched on his rights, the remedies he was entitled to, and the very nature of the court’s findings.

In short, Gachagua is telling the Court of Appeal: the written judgment does not fully match what Kenyans heard on live television that day.

The High Court had already delivered one of the most paradoxical rulings in recent constitutional history. It found that the Senate violated Gachagua’s right to a fair hearing when it refused to adjourn the impeachment proceedings while he was absent. It even ordered the Senate to pay him KSh 50 million in constitutional damages. Yet the same bench ruled that the impeachment itself remained valid and irreversible — because reversing it after Prof Kithure Kindiki had already taken office would create an impossible “dual incumbency” crisis.

Gachagua’s appeal attacks that paradox head-on. He wants the Court of Appeal to declare the entire Senate resolution of 17 October 2024 unconstitutional, null and void. He also wants the High Court record corrected so that the written judgment reflects what was actually pronounced in open court.

This is no longer just a political fight. It has become a constitutional thriller about whether a court can deliver one judgment in public and another on paper — and what happens when a former Deputy President refuses to accept that outcome.

For Gachagua, the stakes could not be higher. He continues to position himself as a 2027 presidential contender and insists the Constitution protects his right to run until every legal avenue is exhausted. For the government and the Senate, the appeal is another attempt to reopen a chapter they believed was closed.

Whatever the Court of Appeal eventually decides, one thing is already clear: the story of Rigathi Gachagua’s impeachment is far from over. And the claim that the judgment itself was altered has just raised the drama to a whole new level.

The nation is watching.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *